e2bn E2BN
Victorian Crime and Punishment
HomePrisoner case studiesPrisoners19th Century JusticeTeachers Area

19th Century Justice homepage

 
Background and Reasons

Background and Reasons

Van Diemen's Land
Van Diemen's Land

The 18th century was a time of exploration and trade. There was also a huge increase in crime. Transportation was seen as an answer to the problem of overcrowded, filthy gaols and also to shortages of workers in the new colonies.

There was also social unrest at the number of people being hung for quite trivial crimes.

Transportation to penal colonies offered the government an alternative to hanging.

Where were the convicts sent?

By 1775 there were 13 British Colonies in America but, on Declaration of Independence in 1776, America refused to take any more convicts so other destinations were looked for.

In 1787-8 the first convicts were sent to New South Wales, to the natural harbour of Port Jackson, north of Botany Bay. During the Napoleonic wars there was a need for labour in the dockyards in England and fewer people were transported.

For a short while the authorities favoured imprisonment in gaols in England, with prisoners kept in solitary confinement or carrying out hard labour. However, after the war ceased, the gaols became full and the number of people being transported rose again.

As well as New South Wales, convicts were also sent to Van Dieman's Land (Tasmania) and Western Australia. The 1823 act also allowed convicts to be sent to Bermuda.

How Many were transported?

Between 1788 and 1868, 165,000 convicts were transported to Australia. In the records compiled by one of the Bedford Prison Governors, Robert Evans Roberts, the abbreviation YT&PS is frequently used. It means 'year's transportation and penal servitude'. The Gaol records show many individuals being sentenced to 7 or 14 years.

What crimes had they committed?

Transportation was originally seen as an alternative to the death penalty and therefore applied to the more serious crimes including arson and highway robbery. Murderers, reprieved from hanging, were also transported.

However, there were other significant groups of prisoners sent including rioters, advocates of Irish Home Rule or Trade Unionism (the Tolpuddle Martyrs) and other political protesters.

People who had been convicted for theft, particularly if it was a second offence, were also sentenced to transportation (see the extended case study of Henry Catlin).

However, not all were hardened criminals. Penal Colonies were often situated in frontier lands, especially the more inhospitable parts, where prisoners' unpaid labour could be useful in the times before immigration labour became available. Sometimes people were sentenced for trivial or dubious offences to generate cheap labour.

Most people transported from Bedford were not murderers, not all had been convicted before and some only for crimes such as poaching.

How long were the sentences?

The sentence could range from 3 years to life. Sentences of 7 or 14 years were common. However there was no procedure for return after the sentence expired. Prisoners were sent to remote areas to prevent escape and to discourage their return. Only a handful ever came back to Britain, despite the varying lengths of their sentences.

When and why did transportation end?

In the 1830's, anti-transport champion Sir William Molesworth, a Member of the House of Commons Select committee, concluded it did not work in deterring crime and should be abolished in favour of gang labour on public works.

By this time several well established colonial areas were refusing to accept the convicts. They were attracting emigrants who could carry out the labouring work. Settlers who had arrived legally resented having prisoners sent to them. Transportation had also become very expensive, and so the government looked for cheaper solutions to the criminal problems at home.

In 1840, Lord John Russell made new proposals. These suggested a mixed system. More prisoners would be kept on the hulks in England to serve their sentences and an experimental penitentiary would be built. Prisoners would continue to be sent to Van Diemen's Land and more convicts would be transported to Bermuda. It was also decided that every man would work the start of his sentence in Britian on hard labour in public works such as road building.

In 1839-40 transportation to New South Wales was discontinued. By this time, New South Wales well developed and was considered a desirable place for settlers. It was no longer seen as a punishment to send convicts there. Transportation continued to Van Diemen's Land until 1853. In 1849 transportation started to Western Australia.

Other outlets were sought to take the prisoners but most refused. When the 3rd Earl Grey took over as secretary of state he proposed an 'exile system'. Well behaved convicts would be sent to Australia and receive their ticket of leave (freedom) on arrival, as long as they did not return to Britain. Punishment for these men started with solitary confinement in prison, followed by hard labour then assisted exile to colonies.

To make this more acceptable to the colonies, the same number of free emigrants would be sent. There was no shortage of prisoners opting for this, as conditions were much more favourable than on the hulks. However it did not satisfy the colonial authorities and a mass demonstration occurred on 11th June 1849 in Sydney. The government remembered the rebellion of the American colonies, and decided to end the system.

After the 1853 penal servitude act, only long-term transportation was retained and it was finally abolished after the penal servitude act of 1857. Some convicts were still transported for a while after the 1857 act. The last transportations took place in 1868.